Teaching the Microethics of POCUS: An Everyday Ethics Framework for POCUS Training

Carter Winberg, MD1,2*; Ross Prager, MD2; Marat Slessarev, MD2

(1) Center for Bioethics, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA

(2) Department of Medicine —  Division of Critical Care, Schulich School of Medicine and Dentistry, Western University, London, ON, Canada

*Corresponding Author: Dr. Carter Winberg (email: carter_winberg@hms.harvard.edu)


Download article PDF – POCUS Journal 2026;11(2):33-37

DOI: https://doi.org/10.24908/pocusj.v11i02.21128


Abstract

Point of care ultrasound (POCUS) has changed bedside diagnosis, but POCUS curricula often teach scanning as a technical skill separate from the patient encounter. Traditional bioethical approaches to POCUS appropriately address issues such as consent, privacy, data governance, and professional responsibility, but do not fully capture the ethical significance of how clinicians introduce, perform, interpret, and complete a scan. Microethics, or everyday ethics, offers a complementary lens focused on the ethical work embedded in ordinary clinical practice. Drawing on five everyday ethics skills identified in existing research, we propose a conceptual framework for teaching learners to align the scan with the patient’s concerns, preserve dignity and modesty, communicate during image acquisition, share visual information when appropriate, responsibly express uncertainty, and clearly close the encounter. This framework aims to make the relational and ethical dimensions of bedside scanning visible and teachable alongside technical competence.

Introduction

A patient was admitted to the hospital with dyspnea and expressed concern that she had not been “thoroughly examined,” despite having a comprehensive point of care ultrasound (POCUS) assessment documented. Diagnostically, the scan provided real-time visualization of cardiac function and pulmonary pathology, superior to traditional physical examination techniques like auscultation or percussion. Despite this, from her perspective, something essential was missing.

This encounter captures a broader tension in contemporary bedside medicine. POCUS has become increasingly integrated into inpatient practice and is supported by contemporary clinical guidelines as an extension of the bedside assessment [1–3]. However, in addition to improving diagnostic accuracy, it also reshapes the physical examination in ways that may not fulfill patient expectations. Historically, bedside examination functioned as both a diagnostic maneuver and a relational ritual, grounded in attention, touch, and presence. When a POCUS examination is performed primarily as a rapid, device-oriented task, diagnostic gains may come at the expense of relational experience. As further integration of bedside technology is both appropriate and inevitable, the ethical task is not to resist POCUS, but to ensure it is practiced in ways that preserve trust, dignity, and human connection in an increasingly technology-rich clinical environment. The field of microethics provides theoretical framing for teaching clinicians how to ethically integrate POCUS into their examinations.

Traditional Bioethics and the Relational Possibility of POCUS

Traditional bioethics provides an important but incomplete lens for understanding the ethical dimensions of POCUS. Clinical bioethics has relied on “principlist concepts” such as respect for autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and claims of justice [4]. When applied to POCUS, this approach appropriately draws attention to issues such as informed consent, bodily privacy, data governance, managing incidental findings, and professional responsibility [5]. This work has been necessary to clarify when POCUS is ethically permissible and assist in regulating its integration into routine bedside care.

However, these traditional bioethical concerns do not address the ethical concern highlighted in the opening vignette. The patient was not raising a question about consent forms, privacy rules, or data governance but was naming a failure in the expected experience of bedside care. The ethical issue lies in how the scan mediates the patient-clinician relationship, alters the ritual of physical examination, and creates a new information gap between what the clinician sees and what the patient understands.

As POCUS becomes part of the modern physical examination, emerging evidence suggests that bedside scanning may carry socioemotional significance beyond its diagnostic utility. Prior studies have associated POCUS with greater patient satisfaction and confidence in the treating clinician [6,7]. Balmuth and colleagues subsequently proposed the “POCUS positive care effect” (PPCE) to describe potential socioemotional benefits associated with the POCUS encounter [8]. In their mixed-methods study of 30 hospitalized patients, PPCE was characterized using patient perceptions of interactions with providers, care efficiency, and satisfaction with care. Higher PPCE ratings were associated with provider empathy, confidence, and rapport, while qualitative findings emphasized mutual engagement, therapeutic alliance, and reassurance through image interpretation [8].

Despite this potential, in routine practice POCUS is rarely structured to support this potential relational benefit intentionally. It is often performed and taught as a clinician-focused task, with limited attention to how its performance shapes the patient’s experience of being examined. The dominant focus on accuracy and efficiency risks obscuring how the performance of POCUS examination can either erode or strengthen relational trust and reflects a failure to recognize the ethical dimensions embedded in routine bedside care. These ethical moments are frequently overlooked and are not well addressed by traditional bioethical frameworks alone, suggesting the need for an alternative ethical lens.

Microethics: The View from the Inside

Microethics, also referred to as everyday ethics, names the ethical work embedded in ordinary clinical practice. Although these terms have been used with slightly different emphases, they were treated as conceptually aligned for this analysis [9]. Instead of identifying ethical tensions only in high-stakes cases requiring formal decisions, microethics directs attention to the ethical significance of routine clinical actions: how clinicians speak, listen, pause, frame information, respond to emotion, and build or erode trust [10,11].

Komesaroff introduced microethics by directing attention to the “finely textured and subtle nature of the interaction between doctor and patient and the social context in which it occurs”[10]. This perspective is particularly relevant to the physical examination, which is not merely a means of acquiring clinical information, but also a relational practice through which trust, authority, and care are negotiated. Subsequent work has argued that ethical analysis confined to rules and principles risks overlooking the moral significance of everyday clinical practice and that microethics is a necessary complement to principlist approaches [11].

Zizzo and colleagues extend this account by grounding microethics in pragmatism and lived moral experience [12]. On this view, microethics does not replace established ethical traditions, but offers an integrative bedside lens through which clinicians may draw on virtue ethics, ethics of care, narrative ethics, clinical ethics, and other traditions as the encounter requires [12]. Its value lies in making ethical attention practical and asking not only what ethical principle applies, but how ethical care is actually performed.

This perspective is well suited to POCUS as it involves close physical proximity, sustained attention, and real-time interpretation of shared visual information. By emphasizing subtle gestures, language, pacing, and positioning, microethics provides a lens for understanding the relational factors that may contribute to a positive POCUS experience. A technically competent scan may still fail relationally and leave the patient feeling ignored, confused, or excluded. In contrast, a patient-centred scan may strengthen trust by directing attention and making the patient feel informed and attended to.

Recent work in everyday ethics offers a flexible framework for making these skills teachable. Five general skills have been identified as broadly relevant to clinical practice: awareness of core values and self-reflective capacity, perspective-taking and empathic presence, communication and relational skills, cultural humility and respect, and organizational understanding and know-how [9]. In this analysis, these five skills provide an accessible framework for teaching POCUS as a relational bedside practice. The framework presented here is a conceptual educational model that applies existing microethics scholarship to POCUS practice. It has not been developed or validated as a formal educational or assessment instrument.

A Microethical Framework for POCUS Training

This microethical framework does not prescribe exact language or rigid behaviours at predefined moments but aims to follow the flow of the bedside encounter and highlight the ethical attention required at each stage. Its application must remain responsive to clinical context. During resuscitation, severe instability, or impaired consciousness, the urgency of care and a patient’s ability to participate may appropriately limit the extent and timing of engagement. It is intended for clinicians learning or teaching POCUS in inpatient, emergency, and critical care settings. The goal is not to create a standalone ethics course, but to integrate microethics and make the moral work that is already present in routine POCUS practice more visible. When embedded alongside existing training in image acquisition and interpretation, the goal is for learners to acquire technical competence and ethical competence in the clinical encounters involved in image generation.

In practice, educators can incorporate these skills into existing POCUS teaching through bedside observation, brief reflection during supervision, simulation or debriefing, and image review that considers relational as well as technical aspects of the encounter. Table 1 maps each microethical skill to an educational focus, examples across the POCUS encounter, and illustrative questions that can be implemented to guide teaching and feedback. These examples are intended as prompts for reflection rather than formal assessment criteria.

Table 1. Integrating microethical skills across the POCUS encounter.
Microethical SkillEducational FocusExamples Across the POCUS EncounterIllustrative Teaching Question
Awareness of core values and self-reflective capacityRecognizing the patient’s concerns and experience alongside the clinician’s diagnostic prioritiesBefore scanning: identify the clinical question, ask what the patient is most worried about, explain why POCUS is being used, and notice when the patient’s concern differs from the clinician’s priority.What was the patient most worried about, and how did this compare with your diagnostic priority?
Perspective-taking and empathic presenceViewing the scan from the patient’s vulnerable position and attending to how ordinary scanning behaviours may be experiencedDuring scanning: consider pressure, exposure, silence, facial expressions, and what is visible to the patient. Watch for discomfort, preserve modesty, and avoid prolonged unexplained silence.What can the patient see and hear, and what might they infer from your silence or facial expression?
Communication and relational skillsKeeping the patient oriented and supporting understanding throughout the encounterBefore, during, and after scanning: explain the purpose and limits of POCUS, provide signposting when useful, share visual information when appropriate, communicate uncertainty proportionately, and summarize findings and next steps.Did the patient understand why you were scanning, what you were doing, what remained uncertain, and what would happen next?
Cultural humility and respectEliciting—rather than assuming—how the patient wishes to experience touch, exposure, communication, and participationThroughout the encounter: seek permission, preserve privacy, use interpreters when needed, and offer choices about narration, screen viewing, or support-person involvement when appropriate.What preferences did you elicit, rather than assume, about touch, exposure, communication, or participation?
Organizational understanding and know-howConnecting the bedside encounter to safe, reliable, and ethically accountable POCUS practiceFollowing the scan: document findings, communicate uncertainty, recognize when comprehensive imaging or escalation is required, archive images appropriately, and remain within one’s competence.What needs to happen with these findings after the scan, and what remains outside the limits of this POCUS assessment?

Teaching the Five Microethical Skills for POCUS

1. Awareness of core values and self-reflective capacity

A microethical approach begins before the probe touches the patient. POCUS is often framed around efficiency, diagnostic yield, and technical competence, all of which are valuable in the time-limited acute care setting. However, these same priorities risk narrowing the clinician’s attention to the screen and away from the person being examined.

Clinicians should be taught to pause before scanning and consider both the clinical question and the patient’s likely experience. The opening moments should frame POCUS as part of the bedside assessment and not as an isolated technical maneuver. Clinicians should ask what the patient is most worried about, explain why POCUS is being used, and notice when the patient’s concern differs from the clinician’s diagnostic priority. These brief, self-reflective moments allow for alignment between the patient experience and the examination to follow.

2. Perspective-taking and empathic presence

Although the clinician may view the POCUS examination as routine, the patient may experience pressure from the ultrasound probe, uncomfortable exposure, unexplained silence, worried facial expressions, or an ultrasound screen that seems to hold important information beyond their reach. Perspective-taking asks learners to view the scan from the patient’s vulnerable position.

Teaching this skill can be simple with direct prompts: What can the patient see? What can they hear? What might they infer from your silence or facial expression? Learners should be trained to watch for discomfort, adjust pressure when needed, preserve modesty, and avoid prolonged unexplained silence. Empathic presence does not require constant reassurance but does require enough attention to ensure the patient remains an active participant in the encounter.

3. Communication and relational skills

Communication puts the ethical awareness generated by other microethical skills into practice. The POCUS examination should be oriented, narrated, interpreted, and closed in language that supports patient understanding. Before scanning, learners should explain why POCUS is being used, what question it is meant to answer, where the probe will be placed, and what the examination can and cannot determine. Permission should be sought not only at the beginning but also as the examination proceeds, particularly when pain, fatigue, anxiety, exposure, or intimate body regions are involved. During the scan, brief sign-posting statements like “I am looking at your lungs now” or “I am going to be quiet for a moment so I can get the image” can preserve shared reality and prevent silence from being interpreted as abandonment.

Additionally, POCUS offers a unique opportunity for visual communication with live image acquisition. When appropriate, and particularly when desired by the patient, showing the screen can convert POCUS from a private technical act of information gathering to a shared visual encounter. As critical information can be gathered in real-time, learners should be taught how to communicate image interpretation that is staged and proportional. Statements such as “I see signs that may explain your shortness of breath, but I need to put this together with the rest of your assessment” are more ethically accurate than overly certain diagnostic declarations.

Closing the encounter also requires communication and relational skills.  At the end of the scan, learners should summarize what was seen, what remains uncertain, and what will happen next. Efforts should be made to restore the patient’s environment by removing gel, restoring gowns and blankets, returning tray tables and patient belongings to appropriate places, and disengaging from the machine.

4. Cultural humility and respect

Patients will not experience the touch, exposure, bodily proximity, technology, and clinical authority involved in POCUS in the same way. Patient preferences may be shaped by culture, religion, gender, trauma history, disability, language, prior medical encounters, and trust in health care institutions. Cultural humility does not require clinicians to memorize traits associated with a group but to recognize that the clinician cannot assume how each patient will experience this examination.

In POCUS education, this skill can be translated into observable behaviours. Learners should be taught to ask permission, explain where and why the probe will be placed, use interpreters when needed, preserve privacy, and offer choices when possible. Before examining a patient with ultrasound, they can ask whether the patient wants to see the screen, hear narration, or have a support person present. Respectful POCUS practice requires eliciting preferences rather than assuming them. This is particularly important in educational scanning, where the learner’s need to practice must not override the patient’s dignity or agency.

5. Organizational understanding and know-how

Although POCUS is performed at the bedside, its consequences move through the clinical system. Findings influence handover, consultation, escalation, documentation, formal imaging, and team confidence. Organizational understanding asks learners to connect the bedside encounter to the systems that make POCUS safe, reliable, and ethically accountable.

This domain includes documenting findings clearly, communicating uncertainty to the team, recognizing when comprehensive imaging remains necessary, archiving images according to institutional policy, and staying within one’s competence.

POCUS supervision and image review should not focus only on technical adequacy. Educators should also query how learners explained the scan, whether the patient was invited to participate, and how uncertainty was communicated. In this way, microethics becomes part of the institutional culture of POCUS rather than an optional bedside courtesy.

Conclusion

The opening vignette highlights a potential disconnect between technically sophisticated bedside assessment and the relational experience of care. Navigating this tension will become increasingly important as advanced technologies become more integrated into bedside medicine. Relying solely on traditional bioethics to guide this integration risks overlooking the ethical tensions embedded in routine clinical encounters. In addition to improving diagnostic accuracy, POCUS reshapes the patient’s experience of being examined and cared for. Microethics offers a lens through which these moment-to-moment ethical decisions can be recognized and deliberately navigated. This microethical framework offers POCUS educators a way to teach learners to integrate technical excellence with self-reflection, perspective-taking, communication, cultural humility, and organizational accountability. As a conceptual framework, further evaluation is required to assess whether its implementation alters clinician behaviour or improves patient trust and relational experience. Its immediate value, however, lies in making the ethical dimensions of POCUS visible and teachable, with the broader aim of advancing bedside technology while preserving humanism and the relational dimensions of medicine.

Ethics Statement

This article did not involve human participants, patient data, or animal subjects and therefore did not require research ethics board approval or informed consent.

Disclosure Statement

CW and MS have no relevant disclosures. RP is the Chief Medical Officer of Deep Breathe, an AI ultrasound startup.

Funding

This work received no specific financial or material support from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

Author Contributions

CW: conceptualization, writing – original draft, writing – review & editing, project administration. MS: conceptualization, writing – review & editing, supervision. RP: conceptualization, writing – review & editing, supervision. All authors reviewed and approved the final manuscript.

References

1. Qaseem A, Etxeandia-Ikobaltzeta I, Mustafa RA, Kansagara D, Fitterman N, Wilt TJ. Appropriate use of point-of-care ultrasonography in patients with acute dyspnea in emergency department or inpatient settings: a clinical guideline from the American College of Physicians. Ann Intern Med 2021;174(7):985-993.

2. Diaz-Gomez JL, Sharif S, Ablordeppey E, Lanspa MJ, Basmaji J, Carver T, Taylor JC, Gargani L, Goffi A, Hynes AM, Hernandez A, Kasal J, Koratala A, Kort S, Lindbloom P, Liu R, Livezey P, Lobo V, Malone S, Mayo P, Mitchell C, Niu N, Panebianco N, Parekh M, Price S, Sarwal A, Teran F, Via G, Vieillard-Baron A, Weekes A, Wiley B, Lewis K, Nikravan S. Society of Critical Care Medicine guidelines on adult critical care ultrasonography: focused update 2024. Crit Care Med 2025;53(2):e447-e458.

3. Jones BE, Ramirez JA, Oren E, Soni NJ, Sullivan LR, Restrepo MI, Musher DM, Erstad BL, Pickens C, Vaughn VM, Helgeson SA, Crothers K, Metlay JP, Bissell Turpin BD, Cao B, Chalmers JD, Dela Cruz CS, Gendlina I, Hojat LS, Laguio-Vila M, Liang SY, Waterer GW, Paine M, Hawkins C, Wilson K. Diagnosis and management of community-acquired pneumonia: an official American Thoracic Society clinical practice guideline. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2026;212(1):24-44.

4. Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. Principles of biomedical ethics. 7th ed. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2013.

5. Chao SK, Liu YT, Kropf CW, Huang RD, Theyyunni N, Taylor LA, Firn JI, Kessler R, Micheller DR, Battles AJ, Rosculet NP, Ager EE, Valentyne AA, Schellack CJ, Hennessy JP, White C, Tucker RV. Consensus-based ethical best practices for performing educational point-of-care ultrasonography in the emergency department. AEM Educ Train 2024;8(2):e10963.

6. Howard ZD, Noble VE, Marill KA, Sajed D, Rodrigues M, Bertuzzi B, Liteplo AS. Bedside ultrasound maximizes patient satisfaction. J Emerg Med 2014;46(1):46-53.

7. Claret PG, Bobbia X, Le Roux S, Bodin Y, Roger C, Perrin-Bayard R, Muller L, De La Coussaye JE. Point-of-care ultrasonography at the ED maximizes patient confidence in emergency physicians. Am J Emerg Med 2016;34(3):657-659.

8. Balmuth EA, Luan D, Jannat-Khah D, Evans A, Wong T, Scales DA. Point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS): assessing patient satisfaction and socioemotional benefits in the hospital setting. PLoS One 2024;19(2):e0298665.

9. Meyer EC, Lamiani G, Uveges M, McLeod-Sordjan R, Mitchell C, Truog RD, Marron JM, Kennedy KO, Ritholz M, Teti SL, Milliken AB. Everyday clinical ethics: essential skills and educational case scenarios. HEC Forum 2025;37(2):179-201.

10. Komesaroff PA. From bioethics to microethics: ethical debate and clinical medicine. In: Komesaroff PA, editor. Troubled bodies: critical perspectives on postmodernism, medical ethics, and the body. Durham, NC: Duke University Press; 1995:62-86.

11. Truog RD, Brown SD, Browning D, Hundert EM, Rider EA, Bell SK, Meyer EC. Microethics: the ethics of everyday clinical practice. Hastings Cent Rep 2015;45(1):11-17.

12. Zizzo N, Bell E, Racine E. What is everyday ethics? A review and a proposal for an integrative concept. J Clin Ethics 2016;27(2):117-128.

Posted in .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *